A landmark
day
by
David Grand
June 12, 2003
That's
how I believe the vast majority of Carrollians viewed the unanimous
vote of the commissioners last Thursday in imposing a freeze
on major portions of residential and commercial development
in the county. Yes, believe it or not, there are politicians-rare
birds as they may be-who actually keep their campaign promises.
Developers,
on the other hand, along with land-use lawyers and individual
landowners whose subdivision proposals were already in the "pipeline,"
considered the enactment of the toughest growth controls in
the county's history as a devastating blow that will inflict
"a big hurt" on them and the county's economic well-being.
One developer went so far as to call it "an act of war,"
which will lead to a slew of lawsuits.
The
immediate effect of the moratorium will be to halt for a year
all new subdivision plans covered by the adequate-facilities
laws, including some 1700 lots that've passed through the initial
review process. It will not, however, apply to: the developments
of three or fewer lots, developments in the towns, and development
that have already been approved by the Planning Commission.
The second measure will stop for a period of nine months most
commercial development on land zoned for industrial use.
Now,
I decided to go to that 11: A.M. meeting, figuring that the
commissioners were eager to vote on the measures and that I'd
be out of there well before lunchtime. And I didn't expect there'd
be any last minute appeals for them to change their minds from
the handful of developers and land-use lawyers in attendance.
Heaven knows, they'd made their positions abundantly clear at
that boisterous, packed, public hearing a few weeks ago.
But
it was not to be, for the President of the Chamber of Commerce
went on a long tirade at the beginning about what the chamber
felt was the commissioners' unfairness to potential businesses
by removing a condition in the freeze exempting parcels three
acres or smaller.
Dick
Hull, a longtime Westminster developer then took that as his
cue to get on his soapbox and express his displeasure with the
proposed moratoriums. (None of their arguments carried any weight
with the commissioners.) And shortly thereafter, the chairperson
announced that no more public comments would be allowed. Poor
Dick looked, to quote the Bard of Avon, as "crest-fallen
as a dried pear."
After
that hurdle had been crossed, I thought the proceedings would
then be quickly wrapped up and I wouldn't miss my lunch. But
again my hopes were dashed on the rocks, when Dean Minnich began
peppering Steve Horn, the Director of Planning, with a bunch
of questions, as to what he foresaw would be the practical consequences
of the moratorium on building subdivisions, and of his timetable
and strategies for coming up with more permanent growth controls,
etc. (Clearly, that should've been done on a one-on-one basis
beforehand.)
At
long last, however, they were finally ready to vote on the measures,
much to my screaming stomach's relief. But then the room became
as silent as a Trappist monastery, with the commissioners faces
as expressionless as those on the Easter Island stone carvings,
and not saying a solitary word for well over a minute. Midway
through the interminable pause, I had to bite my tongue to keep
from asking if I had time to go outside for a smoke while they
were making up their minds on how to vote.
Thankfully,
Perry Jones broke the silence and put forth the motion for a
vote, which Minnich seconded, despite any lingering concerns
he may have had.
Now,
maybe my eyes were deceiving me, but at that very instant when
Minnich cast his vote I'd swear I saw tears rolling down the
cheeks of former commissioner Robin Frazier's picture hung directly
above his head. If it truly happened, that conference room could
possibly be considered as a holy shrine, with thousands of pilgrims
flocking from around the world to see it (for a nominal fee
of course). And I know that Robin would be ecstatic upon hearing
of that miracle in which she was the star attraction.